CRZBY changes
Pick any two versions below to diff them.
- Price
- $39.52
- Discount category
- Close to intrinsic value
- Intrinsic value source
- AI estimate
- Next earnings
- Feb 11, 2027
- Next earnings is estimate
- No
- Company name
- added: Commerzbank
- Sector
- added: Banks
- About
- added: Commerzbank AG (CRZBY) is based in Frankfurt am Main, Germany. It is a large German bank with two business segments. Corporate Clients serves German Mittelstand companies, large companies and institutions in more than 40 countries. Private and Small-Business Customers serves clients in Germany under the Commerzbank and comdirect brands, and the Polish subsidiary mBank serves about 6 million clients, mostly in Poland. At September 30, 2026, Commerzbank had total assets of €612.5 billion and equity attributable to shareholders of €30.3 billion. Its net result was €2.63 billion in 2025. UniCredit is the largest shareholder, and the German federal government is the second-largest. The shares trade on the Frankfurt Stock Exchange in euros. Each ADS represents one share and trades over the counter in the United States in US dollars, and The Bank of New York Mellon is the depositary. Commerzbank publishes annual, half-year and quarterly reports in Germany and does not file periodic reports with the SEC.
- Thesis
- added: The market values Commerzbank on its tangible book value and the return on that equity, and it also weighs the takeover offer of UniCredit. UniCredit offered 0.485 of its own shares for each Commerzbank share, and 17.60% of the shares were tendered by July 3, 2026. The transfer of these shares needs more regulatory approvals, which Commerzbank expects in Q4 2026 or early 2027, and the boards of Commerzbank recommended that shareholders reject the offer. Commerzbank targets a net result of at least €3.4 billion in 2026 and a net return on tangible equity (RoTE) of about 17% in 2028 and about 21% in 2030. It plans to return 100% of its net result after AT1 coupons until its CET1 ratio reaches 13.5%. For the value in the AI estimate to rise, three things must be true. Net commission income and loan growth must lift revenues as planned. Costs must stay about flat. The risk result must stay near the planned €850 million for 2026. The full-year 2026 report on February 11, 2027 is the next test. If UniCredit takes control, it can change the strategy, the capital return and the costs of the bank.
- Valuation
- added: The intrinsic value for Commerzbank is an AI estimate from November 14, 2026. It is not an analyst's value. An AI research agent calculated it from the reports and releases of Commerzbank on its website and through EQS News. The value is per American depositary share (ADS) in US dollars. The deposit agreement filed with the Form F-6 of August 27, 2025 says that each ADS represents one share of Commerzbank, and that The Bank of New York Mellon is the depositary. The method is a multiple of tangible book value per share, in euros, converted to US dollars. The multiple is the net return on tangible equity (RoTE) minus long-term growth, divided by the cost of equity minus long-term growth. Tangible book value is after debt, Additional Tier 1 bonds, non-controlling interests and intangible assets, so the estimate makes no debt adjustment. The interim financial information as at September 30, 2026 gives equity attributable to Commerzbank shareholders of €30,291 million and intangible assets of €1,981 million, so tangible equity was €28,310 million. It gives a net result attributable to shareholders of €2,669 million, a net RoTE of 12.4% and a CET1 ratio of 14.2% for the first nine months of 2026. It says that Commerzbank cancelled 46,649,100 own shares in August 2026, so its share capital is divided into 1,080,847,095 shares, as the release of total voting rights of August 20, 2026 also says. The weekly buyback reports give 7,007,555 shares bought back from September 4 to September 30, 2026, so 1,073,839,540 shares were outstanding at September 30, 2026, and tangible book value was €26.36 per share. The buyback report of November 9, 2026 gives 24,151,382 shares bought back by November 6, 2026 under the €1.2 billion program. The Q1 2026 release of May 8, 2026 targets a net RoTE of about 17% in 2028 and about 21% in 2030, and a payout of 100% of the net result after AT1 coupons until the CET1 ratio reaches 13.5%. The long-term RoTE, a cost of equity of 10%, long-term growth of 3%, the weights and an exchange rate of 1.1052 US dollars per euro, the European Central Bank reference rate of November 13, 2026, are assumptions. The low case assumes a RoTE of 11%, because interest rates fall, credit losses rise and the takeover delays the plan, so the multiple is 1.14 times. It gives €30.13 per share, or $33.30 per ADS. The base case assumes 14%, between the return of 2026 and the target for 2028, so the multiple is 1.57 times. It gives €41.43 per share, or $45.79 per ADS. The high case assumes 17%, the target for 2028, so the multiple is 2.00 times. It gives €52.73 per share, or $58.28 per ADS. The estimate assumes weights of 25%, 50% and 25%. The weighted intrinsic value is $45.79 per ADS. The estimate does not include a value for the takeover offer of UniCredit. Commerzbank has many German corporate clients and a large deposit base, but many banks compete for the same clients, and its net RoTE was only 8.2% in the first nine months of 2025. The estimate does not count on a durable advantage. As of Nov 14, 2026.
- Risks
- added: UniCredit held about 27% of the shares directly in June 2026, and 17.60% more were tendered into its offer. If the regulators approve the transfer, UniCredit can control the bank and change its strategy, its capital return and its jobs. The default portfolio grew to €7,674 million at September 30, 2026 from €6,819 million at December 31, 2025, mostly because of new defaults in Corporate Clients, and the NPE ratio rose to 1.2%. Lower interest rates and competition for deposits reduce net interest income. Commerzbank lowered its 2026 forecast to about €8.5 billion from about €8.6 billion. mBank had a provision of €548 million at September 30, 2026 for loans indexed to Swiss francs, and it faces more consumer lawsuits in Poland. New court rulings can make the provisions higher. Russian courts ordered Commerzbank and its Russian subsidiaries to pay under a guarantee that sanctions prevent it from paying, and more assets of the Russian subsidiary can be seized. The ADS trades in US dollars, but Commerzbank earns mostly in euros and Polish zloty, so a weaker euro reduces the value per ADS.
- Balance sheet
- added: At September 30, 2026, Commerzbank had total assets of €612.5 billion and cash on hand and on demand of €62.0 billion. Equity was €35.9 billion: €30.3 billion attributable to shareholders, €3.9 billion of Additional Tier 1 bonds and €1.7 billion of non-controlling interests. Intangible assets were €2.0 billion. Risk-weighted assets were €180.3 billion, the CET1 ratio was 14.2%, the total capital ratio was 19.1% and the leverage ratio was 4.3%. The liquidity reserve was €146.8 billion, and the liquidity coverage ratio was 136.5% on average over the last three month-ends. In the first nine months of 2026, Commerzbank raised €13.6 billion of long-term funding, paid dividends of €1,189 million and bought back shares for €819 million. As of Sep 30, 2026.
- Checkpoints
- added: Feb 11, 2027: Full-year 2026 results and capital return. Pending. Watch: The net result for 2026 is at least €3.4 billion and the capital return for 2026 is about €3.2 billion, and this passes; a lower result or a smaller capital return fails. Q1 2027 (estimate): Regulatory decision on the transfer of the tendered shares to UniCredit. Pending. Watch: Commerzbank keeps its Momentum 2030 targets and its capital return policy after the decision, and this passes; lower targets or a smaller capital return fails.
- Recent events
- added: Nov 9, 2026: Commerzbank said that it had bought back 24,151,382 shares under its €1.2 billion buyback from September 4 to November 6, 2026. Nov 5, 2026: Commerzbank reported a Q3 2026 net result of €859 million, up 45%, and €2,669 million for the first nine months. Q3 revenues rose 9% to €3,199 million, the net RoTE was 11.9% and the CET1 ratio was 14.2%. It confirmed its 2026 net result target of at least €3.4 billion and lowered its net interest income forecast to about €8.5 billion. Oct 27, 2026: The ECB reduced the Pillar 2 capital requirement of Commerzbank by 5 basis points to 2.10% for 2027. Oct 15, 2026: The ECB approved an increase of the UniCredit stake above the previous regulatory threshold. The transfer of the tendered shares still needs more regulatory approvals. Sep 3, 2026: Commerzbank started a share buyback of up to €1.2 billion on September 4, 2026, to be completed by February 10, 2027. Aug 20, 2026: Commerzbank cancelled 46,649,100 own shares, so its share capital is now divided into 1,080,847,095 shares. Aug 6, 2026: Commerzbank reported a record first-half net result of €1.8 billion, with €898 million in Q2, and a net RoTE of 12.6%. Jul 8, 2026: UniCredit published the final result of its offer: 17.60% of the Commerzbank shares were tendered by July 3, 2026. Commerzbank said that institutional and retail investors tendered less than 2%. May 20, 2026: Shareholders approved a dividend of €1.10 per share for 2025, about €1.2 billion in total, and new authorizations for share buybacks. May 18, 2026: The Board of Managing Directors and the Supervisory Board recommended that shareholders do not accept the UniCredit offer. May 8, 2026: Commerzbank reported a Q1 2026 net result of €913 million, up 9%. It raised its 2026 net result target to at least €3.4 billion and set new targets: a net result of €4.6 billion and a net RoTE of about 17% in 2028, and €5.9 billion and about 21% in 2030. May 5, 2026: UniCredit published its offer document: 0.485 new UniCredit shares for each Commerzbank share. Feb 10, 2026: Commerzbank reported a 2025 net result of €2.63 billion, or €3.0 billion before restructuring expenses, and proposed a dividend of €1.10 per share.