Skip to content

ERIEInsurance management services

Erie Indemnity

By

Updated

Not investment advice. Kevin may own this stock. How we value stocks

History
Price
$272.43
Intrinsic value
Intrinsic value from an AI estimate
Discount category
Close to intrinsic value (AI estimate)
Analysts
Bullish
Next earnings
Jan 29 · · estimated
Pick status
Research only

In short

Thesis
The market weighs the steady fee income of Erie Indemnity against slow premium growth at the Exchange and a change of leaders, and faster premium growth with a new chief executive can lift its value.
Gap
Can close. The fee rate decision in December 2026, the Q4 2026 report, expected in late January 2027, and the choice of a new chief executive show whether earnings can grow again.

Price history

About

Erie Indemnity Company (ERIE) is based in Erie, Pennsylvania. It is the attorney-in-fact for the subscribers of Erie Insurance Exchange, a reciprocal insurer that has no employees of its own. Erie Indemnity does the sales, underwriting and policy issuance work for the Exchange, and it gets a management fee of up to 25% of the premiums that the Exchange and its insurance subsidiaries write. The Board of Directors set the rate at 25% for 2025 and 2026.

The Exchange sells auto, home, commercial and life insurance through independent agents in 12 states and the District of Columbia, and personal lines gave 71% of its 2025 premiums. In 2025, Erie Indemnity had net income of $559.3 million. The Class A common stock trades on NASDAQ in US dollars, and the 2,542 Class B shares hold the vote on directors. Erie Indemnity files 10-K and 10-Q reports.

Thesis

The price of Erie Indemnity depends on premium growth at Erie Insurance Exchange, because Erie Indemnity earns a management fee of 25% of the premiums that the Exchange writes. The fee rate is already at the maximum that the subscriber's agreement permits, so earnings can grow only with premiums and with lower costs. In Q3 2026, premiums written by the Exchange grew 1.8%, policies in force fell 1.9%, and commissions rose faster than fees.

The President and Chief Executive Officer retired early on November 2, 2026, and the Chief Financial Officer retires at the end of 2026. For the price to rise toward the AI estimate, three things must be true. Premium growth at the Exchange must return to a mid-single-digit rate as new business grows.

Cost of operations must grow more slowly than management fee revenue. The Board of Directors must keep the fee rate at 25% and name a new Chief Executive Officer. The fee rate decision in December 2026, the Q4 2026 report, expected in late January 2027, and the choice of the new Chief Executive Officer are the next tests.

Valuation

AI estimate, checked by Kevin. How it is made

Show the method

The intrinsic value for Erie Indemnity is an AI estimate from November 14, 2026. It is not an analyst's value. An AI research agent calculated it from the filings of Erie Indemnity with the SEC. The pick is the Class A common stock on NASDAQ.

The method is a multiple of 2027 net income per diluted Class A share. Diluted earnings per share assume that each of the 2,542 Class B shares converts into 2,400 Class A shares, so the estimate counts 52,289,868 Class A shares and equivalents from the cover of the Form 10-Q (46,189,068 Class A shares and 2,542 Class B shares at October 23, 2026). Erie Indemnity has no debt, so the estimate makes no debt adjustment. The Q4 2025 release (8-K, February 23, 2026) gives 2025 net income of $559.3 million, or $10.69 per diluted share, after a charitable contribution of $100 million that reduced net income by $80.6 million, or $1.54 per diluted share.

The Q3 2026 release (8-K, October 29, 2026) gives net income of $182.0 million, or $3.48 per diluted share, for Q3 and $512.8 million, or $9.80 per diluted share, for nine months. The Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026 gives a management fee rate of 25% for 2026, premiums written by Erie Insurance Exchange up 1.8% in Q3, shareholders' equity of $2,552.7 million and no borrowings under its $100 million line of credit. The 2027 earnings per share and the multiples are assumptions. The low case assumes $12.50, because premium growth stays slow and commissions rise, at 16 times.

It gives $200.00 per share. The base case assumes $13.70, from premium growth of about 4% to 5%, at 21 times. It gives $287.70 per share. The high case assumes $14.80, from faster premium growth and lower costs, at 26 times.

It gives $384.80 per share. The estimate assumes weights of 25%, 50% and 25%. The weighted intrinsic value is $290.05 per share. Erie Indemnity is the attorney-in-fact for the subscribers of Erie Insurance Exchange, and the independent agents of the Exchange give it a steady base of policy renewals, but the Exchange is its only customer and the fee rate is already at the maximum that the agreement permits.

Checkpoints

  1. Dec 2026 · est.Pending
    Management fee rate for 2027The Board of Directors keeps the fee rate at 25% and raises the dividend, and this passes; a lower fee rate fails.
  2. Jan 29, 2027 · est.Pending
    Q4 2026 resultsNet income per diluted share for 2026 is about $13 and premiums written by the Exchange grow faster than the 1.8% of Q3 2026, and this passes; slower premium growth fails.
  3. Q2 2027 · est.Pending
    New Chief Executive OfficerThe Board of Directors names a permanent President and Chief Executive Officer, and this passes; a search that lasts past mid-2027 fails.

Every passed and failed checkpoint across all picks

Recent events

  • November 2, 2026President and Chief Executive Officer Timothy G. NeCastro retired earlier than planned, for personal reasons. Brian W. Bolash, Executive Vice President, Secretary and General Counsel, became Interim President and Chief Executive Officer on November 3, 2026, while the Board of Directors looks for a successor.
  • October 29, 2026Erie Indemnity reported Q3 2026 net income of $182.0 million, or $3.48 per diluted share, against $3.50 a year earlier. Management fee revenue for policy issuance and renewal services rose 2.6% to $847.0 million, and commissions rose $24.0 million.
  • July 30, 2026Erie Indemnity reported Q2 2026 net income of $180.3 million, or $3.45 per diluted share, against $3.34 a year earlier.
Show 5 older events
  • May 21, 2026Erie Indemnity said that Julie M. Pelkowski will retire as Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer at the end of 2026.
  • April 23, 2026Erie Indemnity reported Q1 2026 net income of $150.5 million, or $2.88 per diluted share, against $2.65 a year earlier.
  • February 23, 2026Erie Indemnity reported 2025 net income of $559.3 million, or $10.69 per diluted share, against $11.48 in 2024. A $100 million contribution to the new Erie Insurance Foundation reduced net income by $80.6 million, or $1.54 per diluted share.
  • February 20, 2026Erie Indemnity said that Timothy G. NeCastro would retire as President and Chief Executive Officer on December 31, 2026, and that the Board of Directors would start a search for a successor.
  • December 11, 2025The Board of Directors kept the management fee rate at 25% for 2026 and raised the quarterly dividend 7.1% to $1.4625 per Class A share.

Latest news and filings

Last earnings
October 29, 2026 (8-K on sec.gov)
Next earnings
Expected about January 29, 2027. The company has not confirmed the date.

Every filing on SEC EDGAR (CIK 922621)

Risks

  • Erie Insurance Exchange is the only customer. The Board of Directors sets the fee rate at its discretion, up to 25%, and it can lower the rate if the financial position of the Exchange weakens.
  • Growth in premiums is slowing. In Q3 2026, the average premium per policy rose 5.4%, against 10.7% a year earlier, and policies in force fell 1.9%.
  • The Chief Executive Officer retired in November 2026 and the Chief Financial Officer retires at the end of 2026, so a new team must take over.
  • Large weather losses or poor investment results at the Exchange can reduce its surplus and its ability to grow, which reduces the fees of Erie Indemnity.
  • The holders of the 2,542 Class B shares elect the directors, so Class A shareholders have little influence on the Board of Directors.

Key statistics

Market cap
$14B
Shares of Oct 23, 2026
Yield at current rate
2.1%
Current annual rate, at the price of Nov 20, 2026
Dividend yield
2.1%
Last 12 months, at the price of Nov 20, 2026
52-week range
$204.63 – $301.61
To Nov 13, 2026
Beta
0.24
Vs S&P 500, 5 years monthly, to Oct 30, 2026
Average volume
232K
3 months, to Nov 13, 2026

Balance sheet

Cash
$363M
Debt
$0.0M
Net cash
$363M
Credit line
$99M
undrawn, to November 2029

Cash against debt

Cash$363M
Debt$0.0M

debt covered by cash

At September 30, 2026, Erie Indemnity had cash and cash equivalents of $362.7 million, of which $39.8 million was restricted, available-for-sale securities of $1,369.1 million and equity securities of $152.7 million. It had no debt.

Dividends

Yield at the current rate
2.1% (current annual rate, at today’s price)
Dividend yield
2.1% (last 12 months, at today’s price of $272.43)
Paid per share
$5.852 in the last 12 months (4 payments)
Current annual rate
$5.852 ($1.463 × 4 a year)
Latest ex-dividend date
October 5, 2026, $1.463 per share

Dividends per share by year

Erie Indemnity dividends per share by year
2016
$2.19
2017
$3.132
2018
$3.36
2019
$3.60
2020
$5.86
2021
$4.14
2022
$4.44
2023
$4.76
2024
$5.10
2025
$5.46

2016 has 3 payments (a usual year has 4): a payment date moved across the year end.

From 2020 to 2025, the dividend fell by about 1.4% a year.

Source: company filings and market data, read on November 13, 2026. The ex-dividend date is the first day a buyer no longer gets the next payment.

Questions about Erie Indemnity

What does Erie Indemnity do?

Erie Indemnity Company (ERIE) is based in Erie, Pennsylvania. It is the attorney-in-fact for the subscribers of Erie Insurance Exchange, a reciprocal insurer that has no employees of its own. Its market cap is $14B at the current price of $272.43.

When does Erie Indemnity report earnings next?

This is an estimate: Erie Indemnity may report on January 29, 2027.

Is Erie Indemnity stock below its intrinsic value?

Erie Indemnity stock is close to intrinsic value. The source of the intrinsic value is: AI estimate. This is general information, not advice.

What changed recently at Erie Indemnity?

The latest update is from November 2, 2026. President and Chief Executive Officer Timothy G.

What are the main risks for Erie Indemnity?

Erie Insurance Exchange is the only customer. Growth in premiums is slowing. The Chief Executive Officer retired in November 2026 and the Chief Financial Officer retires at the end of 2026, so a new team must take over.

How much debt and cash does Erie Indemnity have?

At September 30, 2026, Erie Indemnity had $0.0M of debt and $363M of cash.

Does Erie Indemnity pay a dividend?

Yes. The current annual dividend of Erie Indemnity is $5.852 per share. That is a dividend yield of 2.1% at the current price of $272.43. The latest ex-dividend date was October 5, 2026.

Similar companies

  • UNHUnitedHealth GroupShares: Regulation and courts, New management
    Intrinsic value
    Below intrinsic value
    Gap
    Can close
  • TMUST-Mobile USShares: Regulation and courts, New management
    Intrinsic value
    Below intrinsic value
    Gap
    Slow
  • ICLRICONShares: Regulation and courts, New management
    Intrinsic value
    Close to intrinsic value
    Gap
    Can close
  • TLKTelkom IndonesiaShares: Regulation and courts, New management
    Intrinsic value
    Close to intrinsic value (AI estimate)
    Gap
    Slow
  • CTVACortevaShares: Regulation and courts, New management
    Intrinsic value
    Deep below intrinsic value
    Gap
    Slow

Loading your notes…

Read it all? Star ERIE or pass, then go on to the next one.